The Perfectly Perfect Wish
Sale price
$1697
Picture Book · Ages 4–8 · 2020 · Est. 4 min read-aloud

The Perfectly Perfect Wish

By Lisa Mantchev, Jessica Courtney-Tickle (Illustrator)

A girl discovers a magical wish and seeks the perfect selfless choice.

5.7/7 Bookroo experts·4.3/5 Goodreads · 260 ratings
32 pages· 484 words· Est. 4 min read-aloud
$17.99Save 6%

In stock. Also at Amazon or Bookshop.

Bookroo's summary

A young girl stumbles upon a magical object granting her a single wish. As she consults those around her, she grapples with the challenge of choosing a wish that embodies empathy and kindness. What will her perfect wish be? This enchanting tale explores the power of selflessness and the impact of considering others' needs.

"It’s harder than I thought it would be, to think of a perfectly perfect wish."

— from the book

From the publisher

From the author of Strictly No Elephants comes a sweet picture book that explores themes of selflessness and empathy when a girl has the chance to make just one wish.

In the grass, a girl finds an extraordinary thing that gives her…just…one…wish.

She asks her those around her what they would wish for in her shoes, but nothing seems quite right. What will her perfect wish be?

In this pitch-perfect picture book, Lisa Mantchev takes the concept of a magic wish and uses it to explore real world empathy, kindness, and good will.

At a glance
Format
Pages
32
Words
484
Reading age
4–8
Audience
Picture
Lexile
AD470L
Themes & topics
Books about kindnessBooks about wishesBooks about empathyBooks about friendshipBooks about values and virtues
The Bookroo review

What our editors thought of this book

Something “extraordinary” sparkles in the grass as a girl waits at the bus stop. She’s found a wish! Displaying her trusting character, the girl shows the bus driver, who councils her to carefully choose the “perfectly perfect wish.” Vivid hopes flicker through her mind . . . should she wish for pointe shoes, or a trip to Japan? When asked, her two friends and teacher promptly respond with what they’d choose: a puppy, a father to return from military service, and a home for her family (respectively). With each answer, she nods understandingly, thoughtfully realizing that her wishes feel small—she doesn’t “have to worry a big worry” like having a father away serving. In a way that goes above cliché, she unselfishly wishes for everyone else to receive their wish. Pairing perfectly with the story, the detailed black-and-white illustrations are juxtaposed with the bright and colorful depictions of magical wishes. Beautiful greenery and florals on almost every page create a soft, idyllic, and whimsical feel, gloriously showcasing a modern and fresh look at nature with a technique that borders on pointillism. Arguably more amazing than the illustrations is the nameless character who demonstrates selflessness and empathy while contemplating her wish, providing the heartwarming, important example of appreciating what she has and helping others along her way.

The verdict

A heartwarming tale providing perspective, empathy, and selflessness.

Bookroo Editorial

Reviewed January 2020

5.7/7
For the grown-ups

The parent guide

Where this book stands out

Heartstrings

The “Heartstrings” badge is awarded to books that provoke an exceptionally tender emotional response.

After the last page

Talk about it together

When a girl finds a wish on the ground, she needs to think of a perfectly perfect wish to use it one. Do you have a wish immediately come to mind that you'd ask for, or are you more like the main character, weighing out different options?

When she finds the wish on the ground, she tells the first person she sees about it—the bus driver. She also asks other friends what they would wish for. If you found the wish on the ground, would you keep it a secret or selflessly ask others for ideas to figure out the best wish to use it on?

What readers & critics say

Reviews

5.7

out of 7

5.8

The Perfectly Perfect Wish describes my son to a T. He wants everyone else to be happy and will often choose what his brothers' want instead of his own wishes. This book is a really fun read to think about all the good things in the world.

Mom of Boys

Trusted reviewer

For readers who can't stop at one

The next favorite is already out there.

Age-appropriate books selected to help their love of reading grow, delivered right to their door.

Find their book club
Bookroo club box with books for growing readers
The author

More from Lisa Mantchev

Explore Lisa's bookshelf
My Nana's Garden
Sale price
$1699

My Nana's Garden

Ages 4–7 · 2020

Strictly No Elephants

Ages 4–8 · 2015

Jinx and the Doom Fight Crime!

Ages 4–8 · 2018

The Little Blue Cottage

Ages 4–8 · 2020
Your next read

Books that feel like this one

See all similar books

Be a Bridge

Ages 4–9 · 2022

The Thank You Letter

Ages 4–8 · 2019

What Would You Wish For?

Ages 4–8 · 2020

Adrian Simcox Does NOT Have a Horse

Ages 3–5 · 2018

Great Joy

Ages 4–8 · 2007

Goat's Coat

Ages 3–6 · 2018
The Rabbit Listened
Sale price
$1899

The Rabbit Listened

Ages 4–8 · 2018
#1 in Series
Sale price
$1899

Be Kind

Ages 3–6 · 2018
The fine print

Book details

Reading levels
ATOS
~3.2
F&P level
~M
Publication
Published
February 4, 2020
Edition
Language
English
Type
Picture Book
Text details
The text for this book was set in Sentinel.
Illustration details
The illustrations for this book were rendered in watercolor, and digitally.
Identifiers
ISBN
9781534406193

Surprise a reader with their next favorite book.

Spotted a mistake or something missing? Improve this page.

Are you the author or illustrator? Claim your book.

Top contributors: Marmee · Mom of Boys

Bookroo

Book Clubs

Follow Bookroo